Editing Poet to Physicist in His Laboratory

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.

The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.

Latest revision Your text
Line 1: Line 1:
Back to [[Poetry & Science]]
[[Image:cern01.jpg]]
Poet to Physicist in His Laboratory
Poet to Physicist in His Laboratory


by David Ignatow
by David Ignatow
<pre style="font-family:monobook,serif;">
<pre style="font-family:monobook,serif;">


Come out and talk to me           INVITATION
Come out and talk to me
for then I know
for then I know
into what you are shaping.
into what you are shaping.
Line 18: Line 10:
I read your thoughts for a symbol:
I read your thoughts for a symbol:
a movement towards an act.
a movement towards an act.
I give up on thought                             RETHINKING
I give up on thought
as I see your mind
as I see your mind
leading into a mystery
leading into a mystery
Line 29: Line 21:
the most complex being
the most complex being
convention and habit.
convention and habit.
You shall form patterns                         PRESCRIPTION
You shall form patterns
of research and bind yourself
of research and bind yourself
to laws within your knowledge,
to laws within your knowledge,
Line 44: Line 36:
== Comments and Notes ==
== Comments and Notes ==


This poem is an invitation to a dialogue between the speaker (a poet) and a physicist. The title and first line make this explicit: "Poet to Physicist..." and ''Come out and talk to me.'' This is an invitation for the physicist to emerge from his laboratory and engage with the poet. The speaker wants to know the "shape" of the research occurring in this laboratory; the word shape is peculiar in this context. It could be the research, as we would normally expect, or it could refer to the physicist herself, oddly enough. To the poet, the physicist's word is full of symbols and mysteries. The attempt to build a bridge from the Humanities to the Sciences, as the speaker conveys it, is an invitation but also an acknowledgement of frustration. There are mysteries, perhaps encoded in the abstract symbols of mathematics, that the poet cannot access.
This poem is an invitation to a dialogue between the speaker (a poet) and a physicist. The title and first line make this  
 
explicit: "Poet to Physicist...". The first line is ''Come out and talk to me.'' This is an invitation for the physicist to emerge from his laboratory and engage with the poet. The speaker wants to know the "shape" of the research occurring in this laboratory; the word shape is peculiar in this context. It could be the research, as we would normally expect, or it could refer to the physicist himself, oddly enough. To the poet, the physicist's word if full of symbols and mysteries. The attempt to build a bridge from the Humanities to the Sciences, as the speaker conveys it, is an invitation but also an exercise in frustration. There are mysteries, perhaps encoded in the abstract symbols of mathematics, that the poet cannot access.
The dialogue quickly becomes a monologue or even a soliloquy. The physicist seems to have no voice of his own in this narrative poem. The title, then, may be more literal than it seems at first: a one-way discourse from poet to physicist caged in his cavernous and unfathomable laboratory. Initial curiosity turns into an "animus". The long final line of the poem turns into a prescriptive warning, a credo. It recalls the Church's inquiry into Galileo's innovative but heretical experiments of the heavens. This is a reactionary poet, perhaps, speaking from a position of fear and speaking with a disturbing turn of tone. We feel a growing sympathy for the unseen, voiceless physicist hemmed in from all sides. I like this poem because it is challenging and claims no simple moral agendas.
 
== Questions for Discussion ==
 
1) What type of physicist does the poet refer to in the poem? Do you think the poet had a particular physicist in mind when he wrote the poem? Which of these physicists do you think he had in mind (Oppenheimer, Einstein, or Teller)?
 
 
[[Image:RO.jpeg]] [[Image:AE.jpeg]][[Image:ET.jpeg]]
 
 
2) Is a physicist representative of the general scientific community, now or in the past? What type of scientist what you have addressed instead and why (e.g. molecular biologist, nuclear engineer, stem cell biologist, etc.)?
 
 
3) Do you think this is a realistic dialogue/monologue between these two role types? How would the dialogue differ if instead the physicist had been the biologist Charles Darwin?
 
 
4) Have you had a similar dialogue or experience when trying to explain your research/engineering/software project to a non-scientist? How about when trying to explain your research to your friend, your relative, your mother? What obstacles in perception and comprehension did you encounter? How did you overcome them?
 
== Further Reading ==
 
The Man Who Saw Through Time, Loren Eiseley. About Sir Francis Bacon, scientific visionary under Queen Elizabeth I.
 
Any of numerous books about Robert Oppenheimer and the atomic bomb.
 
Genius: The life and Science of Richard Feynman, James Gleick. About Richard Feynman, his work on the atomic bomb, and his later speculations on physics.
 
 
 
Back to [[Poetry & Science]]
Please note that all contributions to Noisebridge are considered to be released under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike (see Noisebridge:Copyrights for details). If you do not want your writing to be edited mercilessly and redistributed at will, then do not submit it here.
You are also promising us that you wrote this yourself, or copied it from a public domain or similar free resource. Do not submit copyrighted work without permission!

To protect the wiki against automated edit spam, we kindly ask you to solve the following CAPTCHA:

Cancel Editing help (opens in new window)